Ask Questions, Discuss Approaches & No Clutter

Prior to 1965 geologists assumed that the two giant rock plates

Solved 3 Answers 2986 Views
[ Update : This question has been nominated for Bounty. The user who gives the best answer/explaination will receive a free GMAT book]
Prior to 1965 geologists assumed that the two giant rock plates meeting at
the San Andreas Fault generate heat Line through friction as they grind past each
other, but in 1965 Henyey found that temperatures in drill holes near the
fault were not as elevated as had been expected. Some geologists
wondered whether the absence of friction-generated heat could be
explained by the kinds of rock composing the fault. Geologists’ pre-1965
assumptions concerning heat generated in the fault were based on
calculations about common varieties of rocks, such as limestone and granite;
but “weaker” materials, such as clays, had already been identified in samples
retrieved from the fault zone. Under normal conditions, rocks composed of
clay produce far less friction than do other rock types.
In 1992 Byerlee tested whether these materials would produce friction
10 to 15 kilometers below the Earth’s surface. Byerlee found that when clay
samples were subjected to the thousands of atmospheres of pressure
they would encounter deep inside the Earth, they produced as much friction
as was produced by other rock types. The harder rocks push against each
other, the hotter they become; in other words, pressure itself, not only the
rocks’ properties, affects frictional heating. Geologists therefore won-
dered whether the friction between the plates was being reduced by pockets
of pressurized water within the fault that push the plates away from each other
1.The passage suggests which of the following regarding Henyey’s findings about temperature in the San Andreas Fault?
A.Scientists have yet to formulate a definitive explanation for Henyey’s findings.
B.Recent research suggests that Henyey’s explanation for the findings should be modified.
C.Henyey’s findings had to be recalculated in light of Byerlee’s 1992 experiment.
D.Henyey’s findings provided support for an assumption long held by geologists.
E.Scientists have been unable to duplicate Henyey’s findings using more recent experimental methods.
2.The passage is primarily concerned with
A.evaluating a method used to test a particular scientific hypothesis
B.discussing explanations for an unexpected scientific finding
C.examining the assumptions underlying a particular experiment
D.questioning the validity of a scientific finding
E.presenting evidence to support a recent scientific hypothesis
Official Answer

3 Answers

Best answer

A) It indicates that  Scientists are yet to formulate a proper reason for Henyey's findings. - Seems to good for now
B) The passage does not seem to be mentioning any recent. Dropping
C) Dont think any recalculations are required. Though Byerlee's experiment does undermine the friction concept but it did not under findings. - Dropped
D) If we read on the 5 line, it starts with big BUT. So this is against the idea.
E) No experiment has been mentioned.
Only A is left.
Q2) The answer should be B.  Though they are assuming, the entire process is not an experiment. The wording is really important. 
B is the ans!

answered Sep 28, 2014 by Partner (696 points)
selected May 9, 2017 by
Jsy Singh

Ques1) A - I am using POE

A - First Read, Keep it.
B - Does not speak about modification that is highlighted in 1965 study - Dropping
C - Too many assumptions inovlved - Dropping
D - First read, keep it.
E - Does not speak about the recent experimentation. Eliminate.
Down to A/D 
In D - there was some assumption prior to 1965 but then a counter statement straightway. so it seems Henyey's study is not in favor of the assumption. Elimnate 

Ques2) I would go with C

answered Sep 28, 2014 by Senior Associate (437 points)
1) - A
2) - B
answered Sep 28, 2014 by Associate (172 points)
Student Speaks

Jyotsna Mehta

Indian School of Business, Co'18

I am very thankful to Gmatxchange and would definitely recommend Gmatxchange mentors to all those students applying for MBA admissions

Your Tentative GMAT Score
Estimate your GMAT score.
The scorer helps you to determine your current level within a few questions you solve.Read More
Please log in or register to use the Scoring Feature
Confused about your profile & colleges, Get FREE profile evaluation today from over 10 consultants.
Follow us and get quick prep updates on Facebook